Our Elf on the Shelf, Nicky Toothy, made his return this year, and the kids LOVE it. Chris has questioned why he has a tag on him, "like he was bought at a store"... but we were able to buy another year of him believing by saying it was Santa's tracking tag so he knows where Nicky Toothy is. Every morning, the kids rush down to see where their beloved elf is... And this year, we've gotten quite creative thanks to Pinterest. He's taken a bath in a Barbie bath tub, toilet papered our Christmas tree, and even brought Christmas pajamas for the kids... And I'm dreading keeping this up for years to come... but the smiles are worth it... I guess.:)